Today I finished skimming reading Great Expectations by Charles Dickens for my AP Literature class. Usually after reading a classic novel I either feel a) delighted from feeling somewhat more enlightened than I was coming into reading the novel or b) disappointed because I didn’t feel like I gained anything from the novel. My response to Great Expectations fell more onto the latter, however, I felt a mix of disappointment and depression. Weirdly enough, a novel has never made me feel homesick-like depressed for the characters in a novel; usually it’s just pity. I guess what I’m aiming at is the relationship between Pip and Estella in the novel.
First of all, I’d just like to say that Estella is probably one of the most disappointing (and slightly underdeveloped) female characters that I have ever read about in a novel. That has partially to do with Dickens writing style; I literally felt like the conflict was unresolved at the end of the novel, and the romantic moments between Pip and Estella were weak. Sure, Estella was raised up my the vengeful Miss Havisham and was a product of her upbringing, but there just seemed to be something missing. Her actions seemed off, even for one so heartless as her; her actions were simply irrational and quite ridiculous in respect.
Pip, on the other hand, I give my whole sympathy and pity to. In a way, he reminds me of the Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby or the Willy Loman in Death of a Salesman. They all aspire to the American Dream but, work as they might, they see it slip away through their fingers; the Dream always staying one step ahead of them. For Pip, it was Estella. Estella represented the higher class; the lifestyle that Pip always idealized. After meeting Miss Havisham and Estella, Pip realized what a shameful and low-class life he led. Utterly afraid that Estella would one day peep into his blacksmith home and feel further contempt for him, Pip decided to change his whole outlook on life, hoping in these efforts to receive Estella’s acceptance that he had always wished for.
But as we all know, the American Dream dies for him too. Estella realizes his affection for her but further alienates him by marrying Bentley Drummle, a stupid brute. (like no kidding. That’s what they say in the book.) After reading this far, I kind of just slammed the book on the floor and was like, “I’m done here”. I was really disappointed in Estella and found her obtuseness to be quite annoying. When I say this, people will just blame it on her poor upbringing, but I can’t give her that much credit; how could she treat Pip like that after he just poured his whole heart out to her? (Even Miss Havisham felt bad for Pip.)
A few years pass and Estella (not surprisingly) has divorced Drummle after claims of domestic abuse. Drummle himself actually dies in a horse accident, leaving Estella to return to the Satis House where she meets Pip one day. Now here is the most disappointing and heartbreaking part. Pip meets Estella to see how she is doing and they end of reconciling their friendship. So, I’m going to opt out of my plot summary narrative voice here and say, WHY ESTELLA? WHY?? After Pip had warned her about Drummle’s bad nature and confessed his lifelong love for her, she still says that they can only be friends. I’m sorry if this is going to end up being a Estella bitching post, but at least give him the satisfaction of having a shot at a real relationship. That’s the least you can do.
So…my rant about Estella is over. I feel slightly less depressed about the whole outcome of the novel. In the mean time, I’ll be reading Fan Fictions where Pip and Estella end up the right way.









